Friday March 12, 2010 1:31 PM ET
SmartMoney
Published August 18, 2008  |  A A A
Deal of the Day by Kelli B. Grant (Author Archive)

5 Sneaky Overdraft Traps

INCURRING A SMALL fortune in overdraft fees no longer requires a poorly-balanced checkbook.

To boost revenue, many banks have jacked up fees and reworked policies to maximize the potential for overdrafts, putting even the most diligent account holders at risk, says Jean Ann Fox, director of financial services for the Consumer Federation of America. "You can get in the hole for hundreds of dollars before you even know it," she warns.

Indeed, financial institutions collected more than $17.5 billion in overdraft fees last year, reports the Center for Responsible Lending, a nonprofit policy group.

At the heart of the revenue stream: so-called courtesy overdraft policies, which allow banks to pay charges that would otherwise bounce. Instead of incurring an insufficient funds fee, account holders must pay an overdraft fee and reimburse the bank for the borrowed funds. Even worse: Most banks use software to single out and pay overdrawn funds without regard to the account holder's ability to pay back the overdraft and its associated fees. "It's the only form of credit that can be involuntarily imposed on you," says Chi Chi Wu, staff attorney at the National Consumer Law Center. "They've laid this tripwire, and there's no point to it except to generate fees."

Here are five ways a bank might try to trip you up with pricey overdrafts, plus advice on how to avoid them:

Contrary to popular belief, using a debit card won't prevent you from overdrawing your account. Debit card use triggers 46% of all overdrafts, according to the Center for Responsible Lending. "They allow the debits to go through, instead of rejecting them," says Ed Mierzwinski, consumer program director for the U.S. Public Interest Research Group. "It's disgraceful."

Solution: Ask the bank to set the debit overdraw amount on your account to zero. That way, any transactions that would put the account in the red will be rejected.

Banks often change the order in which debits and deposits clear your account, making it tough to determine whether you're close to overdrawing. Bank of America (BAC), Chase (JPM), Citibank (C), PNC (PNC) and Wachovia (WB) pay daily transactions in order from highest to lowest, according to a 2008 Consumer Federation of America survey. SunTrust (STI), U.S. Bank (USB) and Washington Mutual (WM) use any processing order they choose.

Banks justify the practice as a way to ensure the most important debits get processed first (say, so a mortgage payment doesn't bounce). But according to Sharon Reuss, spokeswoman for the Center for Responsible Lending, it's really a way to maximize overdrafts. Say you start the day with $100 in your account. You buy a latte ($5), fill up on gas ($50), buy groceries ($35), swing by the drugstore ($8) and then the dry cleaner's ($25). Processed chronologically, only the last transaction triggers an overdraft. Reordered from high to low, however, three purchases do.

Solution: Buffer your account with an extra $100 or so that you don't intend to spend, advises Reuss. Also, don't count on deposited funds until they show up as part of the available balance.

Fail to promptly pay back a bank's courtesy overdraft, and they'll sock you with even more fees. SunTrust tacks on $35 after seven days. After three days, U.S. Bank charges $8 a day until the funds are repaid in full.

Solution: Set up real overdraft protection in the form of an attached line of credit, or automatic transfers from your savings account. It's much cheaper than the average $34.65 overdraft fee, says Wu. Citibank, for example, charges $5 annually for a line of credit. (Balances carry a 17.5% APR, however, so only use these accounts for temporary protection.)

1
2
Next

Follow SmartMoney on Facebook, Twitter & More: Facebook Twitter
Bookmark and Share RSS
Order ReprintsOrder Reprints
User Comments
CherylPH

1 Comments
Would someone, possibly Mr. Banker please explain to me how you can check your bank account on line and have a pending charge one day, and the next day that pending charge is not there, and it hasn't been debited from your account either. Then a couple of days latter it shows up, or sometimes it never comes back! How can this possibly be? This could cause and has caused overdrafts that the account holder has no control over!

Thank you
Posted by: darrilynn97
Guess what yall they got me again, I check the computer every other day to see what has or has not cleared the last time I checked the bank (suntrust) there was enough money in the account to cover the items, but a check was written and was not supposed to be deposited until after the automatic deposit was made, but of course they didn't follow direction, so itstead of paying they tranaction as they can in which means only the check would have bounce they bounce the debit transaction as well charging me for three overdrafts and difference in one transaction totaling 135.00 so I told them once the deposit hits the account to cover that mess to close my account because I can't continue to play this game every other month with them I'm on disability and when my check get to the bank that leaves me short on other things for the month.
Posted by: cinmar321
Talking about fees, how about when the bank totals all checks or charges for the day, and even if you overdraw your account by pennies charges you an overdraft fee for every transaction. They claim they total it, so therefore all transactions overdraw the account. I was charged $350 in overdraft fees, for overdrawing my account by 3 cents. Yes, i made an addition or subtraction error, had 10 transactions hit the bank on the same day. Also made a deposit that day, they sent the deposit to pending, but did not pend any of the withdrawals, therefore overdrawing my account, and charging me $35 for each transaction, although technically only one transaction overdrew the account, add to that, the fact that they don't notify you for 7 days, and you have started a domino affect of deposits and withdrawals that do not clear, and unless you are loaded cannot recover from.
Posted by: CKinDelaware
I think we should have a class action suit on the banks. Not only are their fees outrageous, but why do you think they get robbed a lot. Credit unions don't get robbed as much as the banks do.
Posted by: JennineMaria
I'm reading a lot about banks fair practices and how the they are like any other business finding ways to make a buck. Well then let me ask all of you this...do you think it's fair what is being asked of us..the taxpayer?? Our neighborhood banks are in question about their security. Not greedy some say?? What about all of those mortgage loans the banks wrote?? huh? Washington Mutual was the first to go down for those bad loans. We will all suffer one way or another for the greed and corruption that has taken place. It makes me sad for my children who will have to carry this country's financial burden. Fees are only a small part of their sneakey ways of milking money out of the working people. Stop defending the banks, they are unworthy. My heart goes out to the people, the ones who are uncertain about where they may be resting their heads next year. People rely and unfortunately trust the financial institutions to guide them.If everyone I knew read the fine print of every bank documen...(Read more of this comment)
Advertisements

Related Quotes

BAC 17.03 Down -0.09 -0.51%
JPM 43.36 Up 0.18 0.42%
C 4.06 Down -0.12 -2.87%
PNC 58.34 Down -0.10 -0.17%

Stock Compare

See how the stocks on this page stack up.